“Idiopathic” Injuries And Georgia Workers’ Compensation Denials


An injured worker has the burden of showing that an injury was caused by his or her employment. Sometimes thorny issues come up in proving the causal connection.

The Georgia workers’ compensation system covers a broad variety of injuries sustained in workplace accidents. In some cases, an employer or its workers’ compensation insurer may deny a workers’ compensation claim because it was “idiopathic” or did not arise from the employment.

Idiopathic or spontaneous injuries are due to something personal and not necessarily the workplace itself. A seizure is one example that could occur at work, but is likely not caused by the employment. A borderline injury such as a slipped disk after standing up from a desk could be spontaneous or work related.

The outcomes in these cases can be very unpredictable and it is a good idea to contact an experienced workers’ compensation attorney for assistance. In this article, we will discuss a borderline case that highlights some of the complexity.

Georgia statute provides that “an accidental injury is compensable under the Workers’ Compensation Act if the employee’s injury arose out of and in the course” of employment.

“Arose Out Of” And A Claim Denial

In a recent Georgia Court of Appeals case, an employer denied a workers’ compensation claim arguing that the employee failed to show a causal connection between her employment and an injury or that the injury arose out of her work.

The woman worked as a firefighter and EMT for Monroe County. She sat down to complete some paperwork after returning to the fire station from a call. Then she stayed at the desk watching television while on call. As the EMT got up to let a supervisor use the desk, she heard a “pop” in her knee. The pain increased to the point that she sought treatment at a local emergency room. She needed surgery and a possible knee replacement.

The employee applied for workers’ compensation benefits. The administrative law judge granted benefits, because the EMT had needed to be in the location as a part of her work and suffered the injury when following direction from a supervisor. The employer appealed to the Appellate Division.

Because the employee simply rose from a seated position and did not slip, trip, fall or encounter “any object or hazard that increased her risk of injury,” the Appellate Division held that the employee did not prove a causal connection between her work and the injury.

Georgia Court Of Appeals Decision

The Georgia Court of Appeals noted that the person requesting workers’ compensation benefits has the burden to prove causation. The appeals court cited the peculiar to the work doctrine, meaning the risk was not causally connected to the employment and was a risk that the employee was equally exposed to outside of employment. The majority held that the EMT was unable to prove that her work caused the injury. Several examples they provided that would have met the causation test were a desk configuration that caused her to lose balance or a fire alarm that required her to jump up from the chair.

In a dissent, several judges cited Georgia case law that holds that employment need not be the only cause of an injury, but rather a “contributing proximate cause.” The dissent argued that direction from a supervisor to move from the desk followed by an injury was enough to show a causal connection.

These cases are unpredictable and varied based on factual and legal complexities. A workers’ compensation attorney can help build the strongest case possible. Obtaining the assistance of an experienced lawyer is crucial in responding to and obtaining benefits after a claim denial.

Keywords: Work comp claim denial, spontaneous injury, work-related knee injury

Practice Areas

Client Testimonials

Mark was very knowledgeable and kept me informed with my case. He wasn’t intimidated with the large law firm. I know for a fact that without his expertise and diligent work ethic my settlement wouldn’t have reached the amount it did. He worked far beyond what I expected, meeting with the company doctor, therapist, and insurance representatives. HAVE A TALK WITH HIM ITS FREE!!!!!
-Royce – Fayetteville, Georgia – Work Injury

View More

Mark takes the time to get to know you as a person, not just as a case. He’s an attorney you can trust to keep you informed on every aspect of the case. I received all info about the case as soon as he did, and Mark carefully answered every question that I asked. I would recommend Mark to anyone who is in need of an honest attorney.

– Derry – Riverdale, Georgia – Work Injury

View More

When my adjuster refused to pay for lost wages and for prescriptions, I felt the need to hire an attorney. After a brief consultation, I hired Mark. Within days, I saw results in my case. Everything that happened in my case went exactly as he told me it would happen in our initial consultation. When we went to the hearing, it seemed very one-sided and we won “hands down.” From start to finish, my case lasted less than nine months. My lost wages were recovered, and a sizeable settlement as well. Kudos Mark.

– Ronald – Stockbridge, Georgia – Work Injury

View More

Mark explained, in detail, how the law would apply to my case and assured me it would take some time for me to accomplish my goal. During my case Mark and his staff kept my wife and me informed and updated. Every time my wife or I called Mark’s office we were able to get a response from either him or his staff. When we settled my case, it was more than I ever expected. Mark and his staff were professional in handling my claim. My experience with Mark and his office was wonderful!

– Timmy A.
View More